Also in: Türkçe · Español · Português (Brasil) · Deutsch · Français
What's the difference between 'beef', 'beef dinner', 'with beef' and 'beef flavor'?
Last updated · By Pawfood
US naming rules tie the name to the amount: 'Beef' needs 95% beef (excluding water), 'Beef Dinner' 25%, 'with Beef' 3%, 'Beef Flavor' only a detectable amount.
In the US, AAFCO naming rules link a product's name to how much of the named ingredient it contains. "Beef Dog Food" must be at least 95% beef, not counting added water; "Beef Dinner" (or entrée, platter, formula) at least 25%; "with Beef" at least 3%; and "Beef Flavor" only enough to be detected. None of these rules says the food contains no other meats.
The four rules
| Name on the pack | Minimum of the named ingredient |
|---|---|
| "Beef" (95% rule) | 95% excluding added water; 70% of the total product |
| "Beef Dinner", "Entrée", "Platter", "Formula" (25% rule) | 25% excluding added water; 10% of the total product |
| "with Beef" (3% rule) | 3% |
| "Beef Flavor" (flavor rule) | Enough to be detectable; can come from beef fat, broth or digest |
If two ingredients are named, for example "Beef and Liver Dinner", together they must meet the minimum, and each must be at least 3%.
The trap for allergies
A "Beef Dinner" can be 75% other things, including chicken. A "with Salmon" cat food can be mostly chicken. Front-of-pack names highlight one ingredient; the ingredient list tells you everything that's in it. If your pet has an avoid list, read the whole list every time.
EU labels
EU rules work differently: if a label emphasizes an ingredient in the name or with pictures, it usually states the percentage, for example "with beef (4%)". Category names such as "meat and animal derivatives" may hide the species unless a percentage of a named animal is given.
How Pawfood shows this
Pawfood ignores the product name and checks every listed ingredient against your pet's list, so chicken in a "beef" recipe is flagged just the same. With Pawfood Plus, the full ingredient breakdown shows what each ingredient is. More in how to read pet food labels and the beef allergen page.
Sources
- AAFCO, Reading Labels (Understanding Pet Food)
- FEDIAF, Code of Good Labelling Practice for Pet Food
- European Union, Regulation (EC) No 767/2009 on the placing on the market and use of feed
Related ingredients
Related guides
- How to read a dog or cat food label, step by stepA practical walk through every part of a pet food label: product name rules, ingredient order, guaranteed analysis, the adequacy statement, feeding guide and the small print.
- \"Poultry\", \"animal fat\", \"natural flavor\": vague pet food label terms explainedWhich pet food label terms don't name the animal, what each one can contain, why it matters for allergy lists, and how to get a straight answer from the manufacturer.
- What "by-product" and "meal" really mean on a pet food labelBy-products and meals are defined feed terms, not insults. Learn what they include, why the species name matters and how to read them for allergies.
Pawfood explains labels and keeps your notes. For anything about your pet's health, diet changes or symptoms, your veterinarian is the right person to ask, and their advice comes first.