Pawfood

Also in: Türkçe · Español · Português (Brasil) · Deutsch · Français

Grain-free pet food: what the label means and what it doesn't

Last updated · By Pawfood

Grain-free means no cereal grains; it isn't a low-carb or allergy claim. What replaces grains, and what the FDA said about diet and DCM.

"Grain-free" is one of the most visible claims on pet food packaging. It tells you one thing quite precisely and leaves a lot unsaid. This guide covers what the claim means on a label, what usually takes the place of grains, and what the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) has and hasn't said about grain-free diets and a heart condition in dogs called dilated cardiomyopathy (DCM).

What "grain-free" means

A grain-free food has no cereal grains in its ingredient list. That usually means none of these, in any form (whole, flour, bran, gluten, starch or protein concentrate):

Pseudocereals such as quinoa and buckwheat are botanically not grains, and some grain-free recipes include them. If you are avoiding something specific, read the ingredient list rather than relying on the front-of-pack claim.

"Grain-free" describes what was left out. It is not a nutritional category. A grain-free food sold as complete and balanced has to meet the same nutrient profiles (AAFCO in the US, FEDIAF guidelines in Europe) as any other complete food for that species and life stage. The nutritional adequacy statement tells you more about a food's purpose than the grain-free claim does.

What "grain-free" does not mean

It doesn't mean carbohydrate-free. Dry food needs starch to form kibble. In grain-free recipes the starch usually comes from:

A grain-free kibble can contain as much starch as a grain-inclusive one. Labels rarely state carbohydrate. You can estimate it only when protein, fat, fiber, moisture and ash are all printed; if one is missing, the estimate isn't possible.

It doesn't mean lower in plant protein. Legume fractions such as pea protein are concentrated plant proteins. They raise the crude protein figure on the label, but that figure doesn't say how much protein comes from animal and how much from plant sources.

It doesn't settle allergy questions. Grains are not the most commonly reported food allergens in dogs and cats. In a 2016 review of published cases (Mueller, Olivry and Prélaud), beef, dairy and chicken were reported more often than wheat in dogs, and beef and fish were the most often reported in cats; corn and rice were reported less often. Any protein in a food, grain-free or not, can be a problem for an individual animal. See our guides on allergens in dogs and allergens in cats.

It doesn't mean gluten-free in every sense. Without wheat, barley and rye, a grain-free recipe has no gluten from its ingredients. The ingredient list can't tell you whether shared production lines were used, so it can't rule out traces.

It doesn't mean better or worse. The presence or absence of grains doesn't, on its own, tell you whether a food suits your pet. WSAVA's guidance on choosing a food points owners to the manufacturer's nutrition expertise and quality control rather than to individual ingredient claims.

Grain-free diets and DCM: what the FDA said

DCM is a disease of the heart muscle. Some breeds have a known genetic predisposition. In July 2018 the FDA announced it was looking into reports of DCM in dogs, including breeds not typically predisposed, that had been eating certain diets. Many of those diets were labeled grain-free and had peas, lentils, other pulses or potatoes high in the ingredient list.

The key points from the FDA's published updates:

Research has continued outside the FDA. A 2018 commentary in JAVMA by veterinary cardiologists and nutritionists described the cases and grouped the diets as "BEG" (boutique companies, exotic ingredients, or grain-free), noting that not all of the diets involved were grain-free. A 2021 laboratory study in Scientific Reports (Smith and colleagues) compared the chemical make-up of diets associated with DCM and other diets; peas showed the strongest association with the compounds that differed. The authors described their findings as associations, not proof that any ingredient leads to DCM.

In short: there is an association under study, it isn't explained, and no regulator has concluded that grain-free foods as a group are responsible.

What this means for you

How Pawfood helps

Pawfood reads the full ingredient list, so you can see what replaced the grains: peas, lentils, potatoes or anything else. If you've saved items to avoid for your pet, such as a specific grain or legume, Pawfood flags them wherever they appear in the list, including as flours, starches and protein concentrates. The nutrition view shows dry matter values and marks any value that isn't on the label as "Not reported", so you'll know when a carbohydrate estimate isn't possible. Pawfood doesn't rate foods as good or bad; health questions go to your vet.

Sources

Pawfood explains labels and keeps your notes. For anything about your pet's health, diet changes or symptoms, your veterinarian is the right person to ask, and their advice comes first.

Download on the App Store